mccall 3489 and 5314: when to draft, and when to buy? (summer love story, continued)

this is really a fundamental question once you get a little bit into sewing, especially with the increasing cost of vintage patterns:

when to draft…

and when to buy?

mccall 3489

mccall 5314

i saw these two patterns on etsy and spent a few days playing with the pattern pieces of my advance 8280.  i could see immediately that it wouldn’t take too much work to adapt A8280 to fit both M3489 and M5314 (i even started drawing the bodice on M5314), but i also decided that i wasn’t interested in reinventing the wheel, that i wasn’t yet totally confident in my re-drawing ability, and that the pattern art on these envelopes helped make up for the price of admission.  that said, i stuck with my A8280 skirt on both new patterns, both for ease of cutting and for fabric economy–as well as for design purposes.  i disliked the gores on M3489 and felt that the gathers on M5314 were not as attractive as the pleats on my advance pattern.

so really, it was a bit of a wash.  the purchases may have been a waste.  or the drafting may have been a mess.

McCall 3489
but honestly, this neckline on M3489 is fabulous, and i had never worked with a pattern piece like it:

it’s like a little cowl…cut on the straight grain.  how cool is that?
i admit to being slightly iffy on the fit. i’ve only recently developed a moulage and sloper and i began these before i had either of those tools. so the back is a bit of a challenge and the bodice is not perfect.

still.  it twirls!

and i love the fabric.

McCall 5314
M5314 i’m more on the fence about.  i think overall i made the right choices in terms of fabrics and finishings.  but i did forget to take in the sides to fit me more appropriately, so for most of the summer i was stuck with this…which, let’s face it, is not that flattering:

pretty “meh” although i did have some fun with it, my “5-year-old’s party!” dress.  it was the perfect garment for my friend’s med school graduation and my sister’s 26th birthday.  especially with a petticoat.

but in the end, i dealt with the lack-of-fitting and got this:

much better, right?  it really does need a bright red belt and the bow on the back.  if i ever get there, i am thinking of a bow belt.

and here’s the part where i flash you.  (or, at least, my dress does.)  as always, i got a bit obsessive on the bits on the inside:

no horsehair braid, but nice lace!

horsehair braid, lace and beads in the zipper!

This entry was posted in Finished Objects, Vintage and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s